Despite Google’s ‘do no evil’ company motto, I think their business model is at least slightly evil. You see, this is a company that makes money by people clicking on links. No, let me rephrase that, this is a company that makes money by software reading (or “pulling”) the content behind links. “What’s so evil about that?” I hear you ask. Well, let me list a few little problems.
Reason 1 : There is no correlation between Google getting paid and advertisers finding new customers.
As far as Google’s concerned, as long as that special link has been “clicked on”, they get paid regardless of whether the clicker was actually interested in that product or service. I’ve recently spoken to a web developer that was involved in projects where websites where created to deliberately trick people into clicking on links. Sponsored Google links were integrated into sites in such a way that they looked like normal navigational menu items. Nasty stuff. I’ve also been to web sites where businesses are deliberately exposed to adsense links of their competitors. Guess what they’re going to do - that’s right, they’re going to click on those links to check out their competitors. In this case the advertisers are paying Google to send their competitors to them - just splendid! To reiterate, there are too many circumstances where clicks are not from real prospects, and this problem will only grow as more and more hackers exploit the system against advertisers.
Reason 2: There is no guarantee that what Google calls a “click” is even the result of a human clicking on a link.
I could write a little program that automatically does a Google search, finds an adsense link and then “reads” it. So long as I send the right information so my program looks like a browser, and I emulate human behaviour (by slowing my program down), I’m certain I could fool Google into thinking my software was a person, and thus end up costing an advertiser money. Certainly, if I tried to do this more than a couple of times then Google would detect suspicious activity and not count any more false “clicks”. However, if my program was a distributed “botnet”, trojan or worm, that did this from hundreds of thousands of different computers from different IP addresses, each clicking on different links slowly over time so as not to arouse to much suspicion, well, the result would be click fraud on a massive scale. Advertisers lose big time, Google still wins.
Reason 3: Google has an inherent conflict of interest when it comes to natural search placement for businesses.
In short, they cannot allow most businesses to be found easily by natural search, because if they did, not as many businesses would pay them for sponsored advertising, and then Google’s shareholders would be unhappy.
Obviously creating such a system where every business receives exposure would not be easy, but there are things Google could do to make the situation better, but they wont. Consider for example if Google implemented a “business” search option, where businesses or the same type/category would come up randomly in search results. If you searched for say “Melbourne Electrician” twice, different Melbourne electricians would come up each time and therefore there would be a reasonable chance that all businesses of this type would receive at least some exposure via natural search.
As it stands at the moment, Google says “go ahead and go nuts with keyword optimisation and nonsensical unnatural in-link creating campaigns, because in the end we have just 10 slots on page 1 and we don’t care who fills them. Everyone else will have to pay us for sponsored search”.
Ask yourself this question: Why should a website that is for an electrician need more than 4 pages, and why should such a website need 500 in-links just to get exposure? It shouldn’t. And there is absolutely no correlation between a business that is aggressively optimising and that business actually delivering a great product with great service.
Google is presenting just two choices: Play the frustrating and silly game of creating ridiculous content and links, or pay them big money for “clicks” that they don’t even know are from interested prospects, or even real people.
There’s got to be a better way for businesses to market themselves online that is fairer.